Plushdamentals 2012 MLB Predictions

With Opening Day now only six days away, it is time for my obligatory 2012 MLB Predictions. Let’s skip the talk and jump straight into predictions, okay?

AL East- Tampa Bay Rays

David Price is my pick to win AL Cy Young, and he will lead the Rays to the AL East title. A healthy Longoria and breakout seasons from Sean Rodriguez and Matt Moore will propel them slightly over the Yankees in the division.

AL Central- Detroit Tigers

The Royals may put up a fight early in the season, but no team in the Central division can keep pace with Cabrera, Fielder, Verlander, and the Tigers.

AL West- Los Angeles Angels

With CJ Wilson, Dan Haren, and Jered Weaver (in no particular order), the Angels have the best top of the rotation in all of baseball. Offensively, Albert Pujols will obviously help, but won’t be good enough to win Most Valuable Player. Jordan Walden is one of the top young arms in all of baseball and will reach 45 saves in 2012. There is too much talent for the Angels to not make the postseason, especially with seasoned manager Mike Scioscia.

AL Wild Cards- Texas Rangers over New York Yankees

Both reach the inaugural one-game Wild Card round safely, resting up their pitchers for the game. In Yankee Stadium, Yu Darvish out duels CC Sabathia.

NL East- Philadelphia Phillies

Even without Ryan Howard’s bat for the first half of the season, the rotation holds the Phillies in first place. With Howard back, the offense picks up as they storm through the up-and-coming Marlins and Nationals in the East. John Mayberry finally emerges as a star for the Phils.



NL Central- Cincinnati Reds

As much as this pains me to say, the Reds will win the NL Central. The top-to-middle of their lineup is lethal and Johnny Cueto and Mat Latos create a formidable 1-2 combo for the Redlegs. Latos’s era will rise in Great American Ballpark, but he eventually adapts to the park and finds success. The bullpen is still in better condition than it was last year, even with the season-ending injury to Ryan Madson.

NL West-San Francisco Giants

In what will be the closest division race in Major League Baseball, the Giants pitchers will once again get the job done. The offense will still be statistically one of the worst in the National League, but Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval’s returns in the middle of the lineup provide enough run support for the pitching. Lincecum finished second in Cy Young voting (only behind Zack Greinke) but Matt Cain wins 16 games and keeps an ERA below 3.00.


NL Wild Cards-Milwaukee Brewers over Arizona Diamondbacks

In a rematch of last year’s thrilling NLDS matchup, the Brewers use home field once again to beat Arizona. Future NL Cy Young Zack Greinke comes through with seven strong innings as Mat Gamel is the hero of the game.

ALDS- Rangers over Tigers

In the words of Dick Vitale, “UPSET SPECIAL, BABY!” Justin Verlander can’t pitch three games for the Tigers, but the Rangers are able to defeat him in Game One and their offense proves too much for the rest of Detroit’s pitching. The top-to-bottom power in the Rangers lineup proves stronger than Detroit’s once Texas gets past Verlander.

Rays over Angels

With two seasoned managers, the Rays win a five-game thrilling series. I have a hunch that Evan Longoria will be this year’s David Freese in October. Tampa is able to match the Angels’ rotation with Price, Moore, and Jeremy Hellickson and relies heavily on a steady bullpen. Defense plays a large role in the series and Tampa makes fewer costly errors.

NLDS- Phillies over Brewers

The Brewers offense finds itself in one of its infamous slumps and can’t get out until it’s too late. Gallardo, Greinke, Marcum, and Wolf hold their own on the rubber, but the Phillies do enough offensively to win three close games.

Reds over Giants

They say good pitching beats all, and that is usually the case. But the Reds light it up at Great American Smallpark against San Francisco’s pitching. They win Game Five behind Mat Latos’ effort at home and a large offensive output.

ALCS- Rays over Rangers

The third time isn’t the charm for the Rangers, as they fall to Tampa. Evan Longoria gets the series MVP award as the Rays take this one in six. Tampa Bay does enough to keep the offense of Texas dormant, and the Rangers pitching isn’t deep enough to match up with Hellickson.

NLCS- Phillies over Reds

The Reds were able to defeat Lincecum and Cain in the LDS, but the Phillies a whole new problem. The Phillies blow the series open against Bronson Arroyo and Mike Leake as Charlie Manuel sends out Cole Hamels and Roy Halladay against them. Last year’s early exit won’t happen again for the Phightin’s.

World Series- Phillies over Rays in 5

The 2008 World Series rematch ends the same with Philadelphia taking home the Commissioner’s Trophy. Cliff Lee wins the MVP award after throwing a shutout in Game Two. The Rays aren’t able to manufacture runs per their usual standard with the sound defense of the Phillies in the series. The 3-man rotation of the Phillies works perfectly with three horses out on the mound. Tampa’s only win comes against Halladay in Game Four as they avoid a sweep.



    • chogg13

      I think most people are just jumping on with the Tigers and Angels. If past history is any indication, the established teams usually fare better.

  1. James

    Not because I’m a Brewers fan, but I have to disagree on you with the Reds winning the division. Mat Latos is overrated in my opinion. He had a great year 2 years ago but last year he was absolute garbage and remember he pitched in PETCO, arguably every pitchers best friend. Any time you see pitchers leave PETCO or another pitchers park (Doug Davis an example after leaving the Dbacks) they seem to get rocked. I think the Reds are going to be a tough out but in the end pitching and defense wins championships and the Brewers definitely have the upper leg on everyone in the division with that.

    • chogg13

      I wouldn’t count out the Cards’ rotation of Wainwright, Carp, Jaime, and Lohse. It’s pretty solid but with a lot of question marks. NL Central is the toughest division to pick for me.

  2. Ricky Keeler

    I don’t think Detroit is a jump on pick. They look like the team to beat with the bullpen they have in Benoit and Valverde and plus you now have Doug Fister for a whole season with a great offense and a pitcher’s park surrounding him. I know you are not sold on the Yankees and so far the injury to Pineda does not help, but Tampa needs to show their offense is consistent enough for me to get to the division title. New York still has a great offense, but more importantly, a great back end to their bullpen in Robertson and Rivera

    • chogg13

      I don’t know what it is about the Rays that I like so much, but I just have a hunch for them this year. Didn’t lose much (Balfour to Oakland hurts…wish Brewers had kept him) and a healthy Longoria will help. It should be interesting.

  3. Pingback: Cole's Blog - COOL BLOG FOR BASEBALL FANS

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s